Overview

Anthony's Pizza, nestled conveniently inside a BP gas station on Alter Road in Natrona Heights, offers a surprising and satisfying slice of casual dining. This unassuming spot serves up classic, no-frills pizza that resonates with locals and travelers alike. The main attraction here is, of course, the pizza—prepared fresh and baked with a traditional hand-tossed crust that balances crispness and chewiness.

The setting is informal, modest in size, and perfect for a quick bite rather than a long, leisurely meal. Its placement inside a gas station makes it an ideal stop for commuters, families on road trips, or anyone looking for a hearty and dependable meal without the fuss. While the space may not boast elaborate décor or extensive seating, the focus remains firmly on delivering a straightforward, comforting pizza experience.

Anthony’s menu is centered around classic pizzas that highlight fresh ingredients and familiar flavors, catering to those who appreciate honest, uncomplicated food. The pizzeria’s location adds to its charm, providing easy access for locals of Natrona Heights and visitors passing through who want to enjoy a genuine taste of American pizza without straying far off their route.

The staff tend to be friendly and efficient, understanding the need for quick service in a gas station environment. Whether grabbing a slice on the go or sitting down briefly, the overall experience reflects reliability and a focus on quality staples, making Anthony’s Pizza a hidden gem in the neighborhood’s gastronomic landscape.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Coffee
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite
Atmosphere
Casual

What Customers Say

Donald Cameron
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Just a quick stop. Grabbed a slice of pizza for the road. It was excellent.
Louis Matz
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Amazingly good pizza for a gas station. A log jammed in a little place
Amber Bonnoni
Mar 7,2026
4/5
Stopped to grab a quick bite for my daughter who was hangry on way to gymnastics practice , grabbed a couple slices of pizza. The pizza was hot and yummy. Just right for the time being...
Brooke Beyer
Mar 7,2026
5/5
For gas station pizza, this is my boyfriends FAVORITE. When we do a big food shopping at Walmart and sams club, we always stop to grab pizza and it is really good. The Italian hoagie is also good.
Racin Jason
Mar 7,2026
5/5
I eat at gas station pizza shops all across the United States and Anthony's north of Pittsburgh is by far the best I've came across. We work in Pittsburgh a good bit and we always take the 20 min detour to grab pizza here
Frank 54321
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Typical Gas Station Food. Never had a problem with getting what I needed. Staff is friendly and attentive.
S V
Mar 7,2026
5/5
You would never know it, looking from the highway, but this is the place to stop for snacks and pizza any time of night. The staff are amazing. If you want certain toppings, just ask and see what they have. They cook it fast, are always nice, and are willing to chat. Lost, cold, hungry? Come here. Want advice on a great sweet treat or local baked good? Come here!
Melissa Anthony
Mar 7,2026
5/5
Perfectly chewy pizza crust by the slice with lots of cheese and I didn't even ask! I rated the atmosphere as a too. Because it's a gas station.. how much atmosphere could they have! I'd get their pizza any day of the week.

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday Closed
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Top Picks for You

More in Natrona Heights, Pennsylvania, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!